Product Search | Sugar Plum Bakery

SEASONAL

Anniversary Cake

Delicately decorated like a wedding cake topper to celebrate a sweet life together! Your choice of yellow or chocolate cake iced in vanilla butter cream and decorated in our signature anniversary style.

A flakey, buttery whole crust pie filled with sweet orchard select apples with a hint of spice.

Bailey’s Triple Chocolate Cupcake

Our fluffy chocolate cupcake filled with our homemade Bailey's Irish Cream Chocolate Mousse and topped with our Bailey's Irish Cream Chocolate Buttercream frosting. Only available until St Patrick's Day! Contains alcohol.

SEASONAL

Bee Mine Beehive

Your choice of yellow or chocolate cupcake decorated like a Valentine’s beehive with our homemade buttercream frosting!

Have a blast by cutting this cake and watching a rainbow mix of sprinkles spill out! Made of four layers of your choice of either our buttery, yellow or rich, chocolate cake iced in our homemade butter cream icing decorated in rainbow stripes. Filled with a fun mix of rainbow sprinkles. Add a special message to the top to personalize for your celebration! Serves 12-14

Chocolate cupcake with our made from scratch cream cheese icing.

Bursting with sweet and tiny wild blueberry flavor.

Chocolate cake soaked with authentic brandy rolled in finely chopped walnuts. Contains alcohol.

Our moist yellow cake iced in your choice of vanilla or chocolate butter cream and decorated with a cute bunny face with floppy buttercream ears.

A creamy, rich butter cookie dough topped with colorful sugar. Sold by the pound.

Our famous butter, batter yellow cake festively decorated with our homemade buttercream frosting in an individual size. Available in a variety of St Patrick's Day themed decorations.

Candy Corn Cookie

A tender, sweet cookie topped with festive candy corn.

A buttery, Italian pastry shell with a hint of cinnamon filled with a mouthwatering blend of cream cheese and ricotta cheese.

Our famous carrot cake chock full of walnuts, coconut, pineapple, raisins, and spice topped with our made from scratch cream cheese icing and garnished with walnuts.

Carrot Bunny Face Cake

Our famous, homemade carrot cake iced with our made from- scratch cream cheese frosting and decorated like an adorable bunny face.

Carrot Cake Bar

Our famous carrot cake chocked full of walnuts, coconut, pineapple, raisins, and spice in a bar form topped with our homemade cream cheese icing.

Carrot Coconut Bunny Cake

Our famous, homemade carrot cake iced in our made from scratch cream cheese frosting and coated in coconut flakes to look like a cute little cottontail bunny. Available in half 8" only

A rich and creamy cheesecake bar baked on a walnut crust and topped with a walnut streusel.

A perfect blend of sweet and tart makes this red cherry pie a favorite.

Our chocolate chip cookie bursting with coconut and walnuts. Sold by the pound.

A classic cookie cake made of our very popular Chesapeake cookie dough, our chocolate chip cookie dough bursting with coconut and walnuts. Decorated with your choice of butter cream flowers, balloons, or streamers and confetti. Available in 8" and 10".

Chocolate – Chocolate Butter Cream

Our fluffy chocolate cake topped with our homemade chocolate butter cream icing and assorted sprinkles.

Chocolate – Vanilla Butter Cream

Our fluffy chocolate cake topped with our homemade vanilla butter cream and assorted sprinkles.

Our traditional cookie dough packed with scrumptious chocolate chips. Sold by the pound.

A classic cookie cake made with our traditional chocolate chip cookie dough packed with scrumptious chocolate chips. Decorated with your choice of butter cream flowers, balloons, or streamers and confetti. Available in 8" and 10".

Chocolate Crumb

A cream cake baked with chocolate chips throughout and a chocolate crumb topping. This delicious coffee cake is filled with chocolate butter cream and dusted with fine powdered sugar.

Chocolate Dipped

Our old-fashioned raised donut dipped in our famous fudge.

Chocolate Dipped Butter Cookies

A creamy, rich butter cookie dough dipped in a decadent dark chocolate. Sold by the pound.

Chocolate Dipped Heart

Our homemade sugar cookie dipped in decadent dark or white chocolate and garnished with festive sprinkles.

Chocolate Mousse Heart

Four split layers of chocolate cake filled with three layers of chocolate mousse. The cake is iced with chocolate butter cream and topped with melted fudge and milk chocolate accents. Available in 6" heart only

Chocolate Mousse Pie

Our famous pie shell filled with creamy chocolate mousse topped with our homemade whipped cream and garnished with chocolate shavings.

Chocolate Volcano

An upside chocolate cupcake filled with vanilla butter cream and topped with melted fudge.

Christmas Sugar Cookies

Cookie dough rolled, and hand cut into a variety of shapes for every season and holiday. We then decorate with colorful sugar to create a beautiful and delicious treat! Sold by the pound.

Danish dough rolled with cinnamon and raisins and topped with a sweet vanilla icing.

Our old-fashioned raised donut twisted and coated in cinnamon sugar.

Coconut Bunny Cake

Our famous yellow butter batter cake iced in vanilla buttercream and coated in coconut flakes to look like a cute little cottontail bunny. Available in half 8" only

Coconut Cream Pie

Our flakey pie crust filled with coconut Bavarian cream, topped with our homemade whipped cream and garnished with toasted coconut flakes.

Colored Coconut Cake

Two whole layers of coconut flavored yellow cake filled and iced with vanilla buttercream coated in Easter colored coconut flakes. The cake is garnished with buttercream rosettes and jelly beans.

Cookie Heart Cake

Baked with our made from scratch cookie dough and decorated with our homemade butter cream. Baked in your choice of Chocolate Chip, Chesapeake, and Triple Chocolate. Available in 6" or 8" heart.

A sampling of our very best hand scooped made from scratch cookies. Available in Small and Large.

The perfect selection of our made from scratch cookies. Includes 95 of our most popular fresh, baked cookie flavors. No substitutions.

The perfect selection of our made from scratch cookies. Includes 45 of our most popular fresh, baked cookie flavors. No substitutions.

Cookies By The Pound

Our made from scratch cookies. Available in Chesapeake (choc chips, coconut, & walnuts) Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Triple Chocolate, White Chocolate Cranberry. Sold by the pound.

A delicate puff pastry shell filled with our famous vanilla butter cream and dusted with a fine powdered sugar.

Our tender, buttery pie shell and exceptional ingredients! Available in Chocolate Mousse and Coconut Cream.

Create Your Own Celebration Cake

You become the cake creator! Choose your own cake flavor, icing flavor, and filling flavor to create your own unique specialty cake.

Our light as a feather cupcakes, sweetens up any celebration! Available in yellow, chocolate, and a variety of specialty flavors and decorations.

Our light as a feather cupcakes, sweetens up any celebration! Available in yellow, chocolate, and a variety of specialty flavors and decorations.

A traditional Danish dough snail topped with apple filling and drizzled with vanilla icing.

Danish, Blueberry

A traditional Danish dough snail topped with blueberry filling and drizzled with vanilla icing.

A traditional Danish dough snail topped with cherry filling and drizzled with vanilla icing.

Danish, Cream Cheese

A traditional Danish dough snail topped with cream cheese filling and drizzled with vanilla icing.

Decorated Gingerbread Men

A holiday classic...brown sugar molasses cookie spiced with ginger and cinnamon decorated with vanilla icing and sugar buttons.

Light and airy yeast rolls. A perfect addition for any dinner table! Sold by the dozen.

Disco, Chocolate

Our popular chocolate dipped donut decorated with rainbow sprinkles.

Our old-fashioned raised donut dipped in sweet, vanilla icing decorated with rainbow sprinkles.

Double Layer Heart Cake

This heart is sure to take the cake at any Valentine’s celebration! Decorated to impress with buttercream frosting. Includes choice of our buttery, yellow iced in homemade vanilla or chocolate buttercream. Available in 6" heart only.

Double Layer Heart Cake

This heart is sure to take the cake at any Mother's Day celebration! Decorated to impress with buttercream frosting. Includes our buttery, yellow cake iced in choice of homemade vanilla or chocolate buttercream. Available in 6" & 8" hearts only.

Dutch Apple Pie

Our tender crust filled with juicy, spiced apples, cinnamon, and topped with a delicious, buttery cinnamon streusel topping.

Our light as a feather cupcakes, sweetens up any celebration! Available in yellow, chocolate, and a variety of specialty flavors and decorations.

Easter Egg Nest Cupcake

Our light as a feather yellow batter cupcake flavored with sweet coconut topped with our homemade buttercream and decorated with a colored coconut “nest” and jelly bean “eggs”.

A traditional French Pâte à Choux shell filled with Bavarian cream, topped with melted fudge, and garnished with a maraschino cherry.

Eggnog Cheesecake

A cheesecake blended with real eggnog and spice baked in a graham cracker crust, and topped with whipped cream.

NEW

A bakery classic! Puff pastry dough baked crispy with cinnamon and sugar.

Fall Sugar Cookies

Cookie dough rolled, and hand cut into a variety of shapes for every season and holiday. We then decorate with colorful sugar to create a beautiful and delicious treat! Sold by the pound.

Fancy Jumbo Gingerbread Man

Our classic, homemade gingerbread man...only extra, EXTRA large! A full sheet sized man, specially decorated for the holidays.

Filled, Bavarian Cream

Our old-fashioned raised donut filled with homemade Bavarian cream and dipped in our famous fudge.

Filled, Chocolate Butter Cream

Our old-fashioned raised donut filled with our made from scratch chocolate butter cream and coated with a fine powdered sugar.

Our Signature cake flavors in a donut! Our old-fashioned donut filled with Bavarian cream and raspberry filling, then dipped in our rich fudge.

Filled, Raspberry

Our old-fashioned donut raised filled with raspberry filling and glazed.

Filled, Strawberry Shortcake

Our old-fashioned donut raised filled with strawberry filling and vanilla butter cream, then coated in a fine powdered sugar.

Filled, Vanilla Butter Cream

Our old-fashioned raised donut filled with homemade vanilla butter cream and dipped in our rich fudge.

French Apple Donut

Our old-fashioned raised donut filled with French Apple filling (spiced diced apples and raisins) topped with a sweet vanilla icing.